The Ronald Acuña, Jr. Problem




There is, with no doubt, very few current major leaguers who have as enticing a game as Ronald Acuña, Jr. He has a combination of speed, power, defensive prowess and contact skills that are as good as any player in the game. Acuña is a true 5 tool player, but it is the 6th tool that he doesn't possess, the ability to stay on the field, which makes him problematic.

Because the Braves re-signed him early in his career, which was a very smart move, Acuña has a very reasonable contract for a player of his caliber. He signed an 8-year, $100,000,000 contract in 2019, after his rookie year, which has the Braves currently playing him $17 million per year through this season, with a club option for two more years at the same rate. 

And that talent at that price is a great value and it certainly makes him enticing as a player that Atlanta should consider TRADING. 

Yep, I said trading. Because, despite his injury history, which is two plus seasons missed with torn ACLs, most people in the league would take a chance on getting those monster seasons that might come after the injuries. In other words, the injury worries are worries but the perception of what you will receive at that price is hard to ignore. And that means that his value in a trade will likely never be higher, unless he somehow manages to put together 3 or more full seasons in a row without being injured. Most people in baseball still view him in the same caliber vein as Fernando Tatis, Jr., Vladimir Guerrero, Jr. or Juan Soto. This makes his trade value higher than his ACTUAL value.

Ronald Acuña, Jr. has had two great seasons, 2019 and 2023, which are. coincidentally the only seasons that he has played without an IR stint. He amassed 14.2 of his career WAR of 32.4 (44%) in those two seasons alone and had two other seasons, 2018 and 2021 in which he had 4.4 WAR in both, despite only playing 60% of the team's games in those two seasons combined. As a total, he has played in 870 of a possible 1369 games in his career to date, 73 games into the 2026 season.

I think that the only possibility that a team would have to increase Acuña's durability would be to convince him to play at a slower pace. He has the paramount power that today's game loves, but HE loves the speed game shown in stolen bases and defense. And that is what generally leads to his injuries. In fact, only one of his 7 major league injuries has been to somewhere other than his lower body, which was 2021's 10-day IR stint for a wrist injury. I doubt he would play defense differently, and that is probably fine, because almost all of his leg injuries have occurred while running the bases. Not for nothing, but Acuña stole 73 bases in 2023, the second year back after his first torn ACL (he played 119 games in 2022, the first year after) and immediately landed back on the IR for another torn ACL in May of 2024. Perhaps not a direct causality, but it makes one wonder.

Essentially, with Ronald Acuña, Jr., you get a great player, but you only get that player 64% of the time. And it seems to be getting worse, as Acuña has missed 200 out of 397 team games since the start of the 2024 season. Atlanta has power in other places...Drake Baldwin, Matt Olson, Austin Riley and even Ozzie Albies. Mauricio Dubon and Dominic Smith are also having breakout power seasons. They have speed, even if it doesn't always translate into stolen bases...Michael Harris II, Ozzie (again), Jorge Mateo and Eli White all have decent speed. Atlanta also has credible outfield defense when Acuña is out, as well. With Harris, in particular, but also with White and Mike Yastrzemski, too.

Atlanta has the basics covered well without Acuña and think about what they could potentially get in return. Perhaps a third or fourth starter, as Strider and Holmes are struggling or having injury issues. But, with Acuña on the block, you may also be able to add another major league ready outfielder in the same trade, as well. I mean, after all, it makes much more sense to have 85-90% of Acuña, Jr.'s overall talent for 95% of the season than 100% of his talent for 65% of the season.

Just as an exercise in extrapolation: Imagine that a typical starting player who is considered durable as someone who is playing 90% of his team's games. That would be 1166 games out of 1296 in 8 seasons (Acuña has played in about 8.5 seasons). If you were to extrapolate the 85% talent level on Acuña's HR and RBI numbers and then multiply that number by the 90% games played, that imaginary player would have accumulated 796 RBIs and 226 Homers in that time versus the actual 186 HRs and 655 RBIs that Acuña has given the Braves in that time. Yes, that is not a true comparison, but the potential is there for much more effective offense from a player who has that "6th tool".

Or Atlanta could go another route and act like a cellar dweller and acquire prospects for Acuña. Whichever it is, I would definitely be putting out feelers if I was Alex Anthopoulos. Ronald Acuña, Jr., is a franchise player, but a franchise player only a little more than half the time and Atlanta have plenty of other franchise player talents playing for them at this time and a trade done right could net much more positives for Atlanta than negatives.


.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

NFL Quarterbacks 2025: A Comparative Statistical Analysis by team QB room

Re-doing the Baseball Hall of Fame: Some of these things are not like the others....