NFL Quarterbacks 2025: A Comparative Statistical Analysis by team QB room
We are back once again to sling the eye tests out the window and take a look at who is the best NFL Quarterback or QB rooms in 2025 based on statistics, with 11 categories ranked and then compared with all of the other teams in the league. In other words, based on what they actually did, compared to their peers, as opposed to what pundits thought about how they "looked".
It is a divided league, in terms of how much play various teams get from their QB starters. Twenty of the NFL's 32 teams (62%) had a #1 QB who started at least 14 of the team's 17 games and there seems to be a very direct correlation between starting QB stability (read durability, in this case) and overall team success.
San Francisco is the only team of the 14 franchises to make the playoffs that did not have a QB who started at least 14 games. Brock Purdy started 9 and Mac Jones started 8 games, respectively, and both had remarkably similar numbers on the season.
Only six teams did make the 14+ starts by one QB threshold and still missed the post-season. Detroit had a winning record (9-8) but missed out and Tampa (8-9) just missed the playoffs despite having the same record as the NFC South division winning Carolina Panthers. The other 4 teams were Dallas, who were 7-9-1 despite Dak Prescott perennially being one of the best QBs in the league, Tennessee, who were 3-14 with rookie starter Cam Ward, Kansas City finally hitting the end of their run, finishing 6-11 and out of the playoffs for the first time since 2014 and Miami, who were 7-10 behind Tua Tagavailoa's 6-8 record in his 14 starts.
As you will see as we explore the stats further, the playoff payoff for having a durable starter isn't necessarily reflected in the stats, either. None of that group were average or below, but, for example, Super Bowl winner Sam Darnold's TD to INT ratio was less than 2 to 1. Josh Allen, Jalen Hurts, Jordan Love, Bryce Young and Aaron Rodgers all passed for fewer yards than Baker Mayfield or Atlanta's combo of Penix and Cousins, with their combined 3703 yards. And in fact, while Bryce Young is definitely improving, his statistics line is remarkably similar to that of Cam Ward, who was helming a moribund 3-14 Tennessee Titans squad.
It is essentially a bit strange that I review QB performance in the NFL yearly when I have been trying to make a point for years about the QB not necessarily being as important to team success as everyone thinks. Maybe I am trying to prove my point to myself! A bad team with a good QB is still a bad team, almost every time. Sam Darnold went 14-3 in Minnesota in 2024 and won a Super Bowl in Seattle a year later. Daniel Jones was leading an average Colts team to the playoffs in 2025 before getting injured. Geno Smith disappeared from sight and then resurfaced years later leading Seattle to some good seasons immediately preceding Darnold. These were all guys who were "bad QBs" when playing on two of the most sad sack organizations in pro football, the two teams representing New York. And, conversely, Aaron Rodgers, while not the Rodgers of old, played pretty damn well in 2024 for the Jets and the team still only won 5 games. My point being that to win in football, you need a good TEAM and paying a QB the equivalent of the GDP of Sweden means you probably won't be able to afford a good team to play with him. It is a delicate line and very few teams walk it well.
The best path is to draft a guy a few years before you need him, a la Jordan Love in Green Bay (and Aaron Rodgers before him, actually) or bring in a lower draft pick into an already decent team, like what is happening in San Francisco. Which reminds me, Mac Jones was half of the QB dynamic duo for the 49ers this year and he is another example of the Bad Team = Bad QB syndrome. And Brock Purdy is the current poster child for a low draft pick making good, too. Something great is happening in San Francisco as a model for how to have NFL success without necessarily having the "goods" at QB. Of course, the pundits will tell you that the success of the 'Niners is all down to the QB and also that while they ARE good, they haven't won a championship lately, so....
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The statistical categories that I will be including this year have a few changes. I am eliminating half scores for ties. For instance, in the past, if team A threw 32 TD passes and team B also threw for 32 TDs, both tied for 3rd best in the league, I would add the points for 3rd (30) and 4th (29) and divide by two, giving each team 29.5 points in that category. Now, I will assign a place to tied teams determined by other factors. If team A throws for 32 TDs in 607 attempts, for example, and team B has the same total of TDs in 557 attempts, team B will be above team A in place and score for that category. In addition, I will be combining a half score of rushing yards and a half score for number of times sacked into a single category score that I will call Escapability.
Those two scores will be added to each other and divided by 2 (so you will see some half points here) and used as a single score along with the usual suspects, which are Completions, Attempts, Completion Percentage, Total Yards Passing, TDs, Interceptions, Yards per Attempt and per Completion, QB Rating and the Sports Thinker's favorite, TD/INT Ratio. All of this brings us to a total of eleven scoring categories.
Hopefully, all of this gives a complete picture of a QB room while adjusting for each team's discrepancies in coaching styles and overall roster talent.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Overall Scores:
Team Total Score Average Category Score
1) Los Angeles Rams 300 points 27.272
2) New England Patriots 284.5 points 25.863
3) Dallas Cowboys 280 points 25.454
4) Detroit Lions 279.5 points 25.409
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
5) Buffalo Bills 251 points 22.818
6) San Francisco 49ers 239 points 21.727
7) Green Bay Packers 238.5 points 21.681
8) Chicago Bears 233.5 points 21.227
9) Arizona Cardinals 217 points 19.727
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
10) Houston Texans 208 Points 18.909
11) Indianapolis Colts 201.5 points 18.318
12) Jacksonville Jaguars 200.5 points 18.227
13) Seattle Seahawks 194 points 17.636
14) Philadelphia Eagles 193 points 17.545
15) Cincinnati Bengals 192.5 points 17.500
16) Denver Broncos 191 points 17.363
17) Tampa Bay Buccaneers 188.5 points 17.136
18) Los Angeles Chargers 186.5 points 16.954
19) New Orleans Saints 183.5 points 16.681
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
20) Kansas City Chiefs 176.5 points 16.045
21) Baltimore Ravens 173.5 points 15.772
22) Pittsburgh Steelers 172.5 points 15.681
23) New York Giants 163 points 14.818
24) Atlanta Falcons 160 points 14.545
--------------------------------------------------
25) Washington Commanders 125 points 11.363
26) Carolina Panthers 120.5 points 10.954
27) Miami Dolphins 102 points 9.272
28) Tennessee Titans 101 points 9.181
29) Las Vegas Raiders 86.5 points 7.863
30) Minnesota Vikings 58.5 points 5.318
31) Cleveland Browns 55.5 points 5.045
32) New York Jets 51.5 points 4.681
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Overview and general thoughts
Within the top nine, the Elite and the Very Good groups of QB rooms, you will find six playoff teams, including the eventual AFC Champs, New England and two other teams, Dallas and Detroit who have a combined 16-17-1 record. In fact, Detroit finished 9-8 but lost three of their last 4 games after an 8-5 start to do in their playoff hopes. Plus, two of the losses in the season were to Minnesota, who had the same record but were not nearly as good an overall team. Except when they played the Lions, of course.
Dallas and Detroit highlight some of my major disappointments, teams whose records were not commensurate to their good to very good quarterback stats. Cincinnati (17.500, 14th best in the league) had a 6-11 record. Indianapolis (18.318, 11th in the league), were 8-3 until Daniel Jones was hurt and they lost their final 6 games to finish 8-9.
The New York Giants (14.818 average score, 23rd in the NFL) didn't have "great" QB play but were better than expected at that position and may just have something in Jaxson Dart. And yet, they only finished 4-13, only one game better than their stadium mates, the Jets, who finished last in the league in QB stats.
Even more surprising was that first, the Arizona Cardinals were the 9th best QB room in the league with an average of 19.727 (I've been telling you for YEARS that Jacoby Brissett is a good QB) but finished at 3-14. Kansas City also was disappointing, finishing 6-11. Yes, they were only 20th best in the league, but Patrick Mahomes is still Patrick Mahomes.
In terms of positive surprises, Seattle overplayed their 13th best QB room to a 14-3 record and eventual championship. Miami somehow managed to win 7 games despite a QB room that finished a collective 27th in the league in terms of stats. Minnesota was probably the biggest surprise, finishing 9-8 and barely missing the playoffs despite the 3rd worst QB situation in the league. Carolina won the NFC South with a losing record (8-9) and a QB room that was 26th in the league, so they certainly over-performed their QB play.
Additionally, as a comparison, New Orleans managed to win only 6 games in a weak division with the 19th best QB room, while Cleveland managed to win 5 games with the second worst QB room in the NFL in 2025.
What all of this tells us is that success as a TEAM is not guaranteed by QB success. Conversely, a team can be successful without a stats monster at QB, as well. Basically, the same message that I have been trying to convey for many years, chiefly that the QB position is vastly over-valued in a sport where a team has 53 members.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Elites
1) Los Angeles Rams Average category score: 27.272
Record: 12-5 Lost in NFC Championship game
The only real question facing the Rams is the question of just how long Matthew Stafford wants to continue playing. Stafford signed a 2-year restructured contract a little less than a year ago which will keep him signed until the end of the 2026 season, when he will be 39 years old. Stetson Bennett, who is 29 and with hardly any NFL experience is the backup as last year's number 2 QB, Jimmy Garoppolo, is now a free agent.
Rumors are that Stafford will play one more year, attempt to win one more Super Bowl and then hang up his cleats regardless of the outcome. As for the Rams, I guess they will just ride the horse one more time and let 2027 take care of itself. There aren't many great QB free agent options for 2026 or 2027 and it is likely that the Rams will be too good to get a low draft pick to pick one, barring a trade.
The Rams QB Room WAS Matthew Stafford in 2025. He finished in the top 7 in the league statistically in nine of the eleven scoring categories, finishing first in both TD passes thrown and Ratio. Escapability and Completion Percentage were the only categories the fell below the top seven, and he was still at or above league average (16th and 14th best, respectively) in those two.
2) New England Patriots Average Category score: 25.863
Record: 14-3 AFC East Champions, Lost in Super Bowl
Another essentially one-man QB Room as Drake Maye held down the duty for the entire year with the exception of the 10 passes that Joshua Dobbs threw in 2025. In consideration of Maye's age, this is probably the best QB situation going forward for any NFL team into the near future, with the possible exceptions of Green Bay or Chicago.
Maye led the league in three categories, Completion Percentage, QBR and Yards per Attempt and in the top four in four other categories, Yards, Ratio, TDs thrown and Yards per Completion.
Admittedly, his 8th worst score in Pass Attempts informs the higher scores in his better categories and harkens to coaching decisions made by Mike Vrabel, in his first year as the head coach in New England. A coach with a history of not being a pass happy offensively and a young, largely unproven QB tells the tale. I would not be surprised to see a bit more passing from New England in the coming season as Drake Maye has proven he is definitely a high-level NFL QB in just two seasons.
3) Dallas Cowboys Average category score: 25.454
Record: 7-9-1 2nd in NFC East, missed playoffs
For all of Jerry Jones' many documented faults as owner, and more so as General Manager of the Cowboys, he absolutely hit one out of the park in drafting Dak Prescott in the 4th round in 2016. This is my 4th analysis of NFL QBs and Prescott or the Cowboys have finished 12th, 1st, 20th (last year, when he missed 9 games) and 3rd this year. Outside of Tom Brady and possibly Prescott's immediate predecessor, Tony Romo, he is the best day three/undrafted QB signing in the last 30 years in the NFL. And yes, I remembered Brock Purdy when I said that. More on him later.
Much like with the Rams and Patriots above, Dak Prescott was, essentially, the entire Cowboys QB room. Backup Joe Milton got into 4 games without a start and most of his playing time was in the season finale against the Giants as the Cowboys were playing for nothing at that point. Prescott's numbers were in the top 6 in the league in 7 of the 11 categories rated, leading the NFL in Passing Yards and finishing second in Completions and Completion Percentage. Prescott was below league average in only one category, Interceptions, which dragged down his Ratio despite his 6th best finish in TD passes thrown.
4) Detroit Lions Average category score: 25.409
Record: 9-8 Last in NFC North, missed playoffs
Yes, okay, the Lions still have not won a Super Bowl, but the trade a few years back that had the Rams sending Jared Goff to Detroit for Matthew Stafford may be the ultimate win-win trade in NFL history.
The Rams were largely unsatisfied with Goff, largely stemming, I believe, from a moribund offensive performance against the Patriots in Super Bowl 53, three seasons before he was traded. Meanwhile, Stafford, much like his teammate, Calvin Johnson, toiled for years in Detroit, playing with greatness for teams that were anything but.
Then the trade happened. The Rams won their Super Bowl the season after the trade, 2021, and have been one of the better teams in the league since. Goff resurrected his reputation and has become one of the best QBs in the league and Detroit has gotten increasingly better, definitively improving from Stafford's era.
And 2025 was no exception for Jared Goff, who played almost 100% of Detroit's offensive snaps at QB. Goff did not finish first in any statistical category, but was second or third in TDs, Yards and Ratio. A fourteenth-place finish in QBR was the only dent in the average beyond the bottom ten in the league Escapability score. Every other category score was in the top ten or better.
The Very Good
5) Buffalo Bills Average category score: 22.818
Record: 12-5 second in the AFC East, lost in OT at Denver in the Divisional round
Josh Allen IS the de facto QB room in Buffalo, but this is the first team on the list with a significant backup stats addition being made. Mitch Trubisky didn't start any games but played enough to have a game's worth of stats to add to the total, and in particular, his 4 TD passes and no Interceptions makes a big contribution to the overall quality of the room.
The Bills represent the first significant category average drop-off in the list as their average score falls over 2.5 points from the #4 Lions one spot above them. Buffalo only finished in the top three in the league in one category, Yards per attempt. Largely, I imagine, because they also have the 9th fewest pass attempts in the league in 2025. What made the Bills score so high was a solid placement in almost every category, finishing in the top 13 in the league in 9 of the 11 total categories. Nothing too flashy here, just good solid, top of the league quality all around, including Escapability, as the Bills are the first team in the top five of this list with a score in the top 11 or above in the league in that category.
There is a reason that the Bills are so good every year and that reason is because Josh Allen is very good to great all around in ALL aspects of the QB position's skill set. Unfortunately, unless they win a Super Bowl, the fans always start to get sick of a team winning but not winning it all and they all invariably end up blaming the QB when that happens.
6) San Francisco 49ers Average category score: 21.727
Record: 12-5 3rd in the NFC West, lost to Seattle in the divisional round
Now THIS is an interesting case of chicken vs. egg....are the 49ers QBs great because of the scheme and team or are the QBs making the team good?
The 49ers have just rolled on and on for years under Kyle Shanahan, throwing in the occasional clunker of a season, but generally being in the playoffs and while they haven't won a Super Bowl since the 90s, they have played in the game twice in the last 7 years. And they have done this largely with either Jimmy Garoppolo or Brock Purdy as the starting QB.
I firmly believe that Brock Purdy is way better a QB than his status as Mr. Irrelevant would attest. But, as 2025 stats show, he was not any better than backup Mac Jones on a playoff team.
In fact, both QBs statistics are remarkably similar. Brock Purdy started 9 games and Mac Jones eight. Jones completed 201 passes in 289 attempts (69.5%), Purdy 197 out of 284 (69.3%). They both topped 2100 yards passing with Purdy topping Jones by 16 yards total. Purdy threw 20 TDs with 10 Interceptions, a 2-1 ratio compared with Jones' 13 TDs/6 INTs, a 2.166-1 ratio. In other words, they were essentially the same QB.
And, together, they were the 6th best QB in the league. They had 5 category scores in the top 6 in the league, with Completion Percentage being their best score, 3rd best in the league. Three more scores are in the top 13 in the league. The other 3 categories are all below league average, the lowest being the Interceptions category, finishing 6th worst which leads directly to their 9th worst Ratio score.
And NONE of this answers the Tom Brady/Bill Belichick question that surrounds the 49ers. Is it the QBs or the coach? Let the arguments begin. Meanwhile, Mac Jones will remain through this season as the "backup" before what will surely be sharp interest for him in the free agent market after the 2026 campaign.
7) Green Bay Packers Average category score: 21.681
Record: 9-7-1 2nd in NFC North, lost in the Wild Card round
Most of this QB room was Jordan Love, with 3rd stringer Clayton Tune getting a start in the finale' and Malik Willis likely playing himself into a starter's contract somewhere. Willis played in 4 games and started two in 2025 and was outstanding. Tack that onto his brief stints in 2024 (700 yards passing, 6 TDs and 0 INTs with a 78% completion percentage in those two seasons) and it seems that Malik Willis has the goods. All of that said, however, his future is elsewhere and the Packers QB now and future is Jordan Love.
The Packers seem to be the one franchise in the league that has consistently learned to draft the future QB while the current one still has some life in his game. Thus, Brett Favre begat Aaron Rodgers, who begat Jordan Love. Yes, you get fewer playing years on the rookie contract, but you get better play during those years almost always.
Green Bay didn't pass a lot in 2025, finishing 6th worst in the league in Attempts, but made the most of it by scoring four places higher in Completions and a further 5 more places higher in Yards passing. Jacoby Brissett, by comparison, only started 12 games, with playing time in two others and yet he attempted only 4 fewer passes than the entire Packers team in 2025.
And from all of this you would gather, correctly, that the Packers QB room, again mostly Jordan Love, were highly placed in Yards per attempt and Yards per completion, both in the NFL top 7. And neither of those were their highest categories, which were second best QBR and third best in fewest Interceptions thrown. What a closer look at these numbers tells me is that Love is even a little bit better than it seems on first glance. The Attempts stat is a coaching style and discretion stat, a playbook stat. Jordan Love parlayed the relatively few attempts into mid-level scores in Yards and TDs, which are cumulative outcomes. In other words, he outpaced where he should have been in accumulated statistics based on the small number of attempts. To put it as a cliche, he made hay while the sun shone.
8) Chicago Bears Average category score: 21.227
Record: 11-6 NFC North Champs, lost in the Divisional Round
Okay, apparently the Bears finally got a QB right. Caleb Williams is very good. Notably, however, they finally found a good coach, as well. Ben Johnson was hired, Caleb Williams took flight and the Bears were better than they have been in quite a while. But what that also might mean is that Justin Fields or Mitch Trubisky were better than they seemed. We are back to the "is it a bad QB or a bad team?" question. And the last decade plus of Bears football has definitely been a coach and/or QB killer period.
The most positive aspect of Caleb Williams' 2025 season was that he threw the fewest Interceptions of any NFL QB. That is BIG!!! And that was while throwing the 11th most passes in the league. In addition, however, he also had the second lowest Completion percentage in the league. What this tells me is that Williams understands very early in his career a very important QB trait that usually comes much later, which is being risk averse. In other words, he knows when to take an incompletion, throwing the ball away instead of throwing it to the "enemy".
Caleb Williams was top 11 in the league in 6 categories, as diverse as Escapability, Yards per completion, TDs thrown and Ratio (it helps when you have thrown the fewest INTs in the league), with total Completions only being lower than league average other than the aforementioned Completion percentage.
The Bears QB future looks great, whether they are in Chicago or Indiana. In fact, in consideration of how everyone played last year in the division, the NFC North might be the best division in the current NFL, right there with the NFC West.
9) Arizona Cardinals Average category score: 19.727
Record: 3-14 Missed playoffs (obviously)
SURPRISE!!!!! The 3-14 Cardinals were actually fine at QB last year. Proof that you can get really good play out of a guy on a $6 million a year contract, but also that really good QB play doesn't guarantee a good team no matter where the guy was drafted or what you pay them.
I have been telling everyone for years, give Jacoby Brissett a starting job and just leave him alone. Put Brissett on last year's Dolphins or Vikings, who both played above the level of their QB play as a team, and you would likely have been sailing right into the playoffs.
The Cardinals actually got good play from both Brissett and the normal starter, Kyler Murray, as a combo, although Murray missed most of 2025 due to injury. And it is very likely that Arizona may trade him as they have Brissett signed for another year and might look to draft a starter at QB with the third pick in the draft. Obviously, considering the contract Murray is signed to versus the quality of the team, there is no point in keeping him when you likely won't improve enough overall in the last two years of his contract before a club option year in year three. (Murray was released by the Cardinals on March 11 and signed a one-year contract with the Vikings the next day)
As for their stats position relative to the league, Arizona passed A LOT! First in both Attempts and Completions and fifth in Yards passing. They were also in the top half of the league in TDs thrown and fewest Interceptions which naturally leads to a Ratio score in the top 10, as well. Unfortunately, QBR, yards per Attempt and Completion and Escapability all fall into the bottom half of the NFL.
The Middle Tier - top group
10) Houston Texans Average category score: 18.909
Record: 12-5, second in the AFC South. Lost in Divisional round of playoffs
C.J. Stroud was absolutely amazing during his rookie campaign three seasons ago. And while his stats have flagged a little in different areas during each of the following seasons, he is still very good, and he represents the bulk of Houston's statistical story for 2025, although he missed three starts and Davis Mills got 27% of the Texans' pass attempts on the season, starting 3 games and playing in 3 more.
The Texans started the 2025 season 0-3 and got to 3-5 before winning the final 9 games of the season.
After his stellar rookie season, Stroud's numbers waned a bit in his sophomore 2024 campaign even though it was his only season in which he started all 17 games. Mostly, however, two things are noticeable. First, Stroud attempted more passes and threw for more yards as a rookie out of necessity, as Houston's running game was weak during his rookie season, with Devin Singletary leading the team with 898 yards. In Stroud's second year, Joe Mixon rushed for over 1000 yards and the combo of Nick Chubb and rookie Woody Marks bested that, grabbing 1200+ yards between them in 2025. So, C. J. Stroud passed for less attempts and yards because the play calling relied more heavily on the run game.
The second item was that Stroud had a monster 4.6 to 1 ratio in 2023, which precipitously dropped to a 1.67 to 1 in 2024, rebounding to a more respectable 2.38 to 1 last season.
Regardless of all of that, C. J. Stroud is a well above average young QB in the NFL and the combination of him and head coach DeMeco Ryans has led the Texans into the playoffs three straight years. In 2025, the stats highlights were top 9 in the NFL finishes in fewest INTs thrown, Pass Attempts and Ratio. They were also above league average in Completions, QBR, Yards thrown and Escapability.
11) Indianapolis Colts Average category score: 18.318
Record: 8-9, missed playoffs
Indianapolis was in a definitive QB wasteland following the unfortunate release of Carson Wentz following a pretty good 2021 season. The 2022 through 2024 seasons saw the likes of Nick Foles, a final season Matt Ryan, Gardner Minshew, Joe Flacco and Anthony Richardson behind center as primary QBs. And many thought it was "same old, same old" when they signed Daniel Jones before the 2025 season.
Turns out that the Jones they got was the same guy who took the Giants to the playoffs in 2022. And that Daniel Jones is a solid, above average NFL QB, who, by the way, is a sneaky good runner, as well.
The Colts started 2025 with an 8-2 record after 10 games and all was right with their world. Then they got to the tough part of the season, with a loss to Kansas City in game eleven before six straight losses to playoff bound teams to close out 2025, the last 4 of which came after Jones' season ending injury that occurred early in the game 13 loss to Jacksonville. After that, the Colts signed recently retired Phillip Rivers, and between him and Riley Leonard, they got two decent games and two not so great games in the final 4 losses. In my opinion, I am not sure if they win more than one of those games with Jones behind center. Only 4 of their first 10 games were against playoff teams and they went 8-2. Kansas City was the only opponent in those season-ending 7 straight losses that was not ultimately a playoff team, but at the time they played in week 12, the Chiefs were 5-5 and in the hunt still.
Indianapolis as a whole finished in the top 13 in the NFL in 5 statistical categories, with the best score in QBR and Yards Passing, in which they were 8th best in the league.The Colts QBs threw the 8th most Interceptions in the league, their worst category. This led to a below league average score in Ratio and they were also below average in Attempts, which makes sense when you have Jonathan Taylor rushing for 1500+ yards.
12) Jacksonville Jaguars Average category score: 18.227
Record: 13-4, AFC South Champs, lost in Wild Card Playoff round
Trevor Lawrence WAS the Jaguars QB room last year, as is befitting of someone who has started all but 8 of his team's 85 games in his first five NFL seasons. Backup Nick Mullens got into 5 games and completed just 3 passes on the season.
The 2024 season was Lawrence's worst since his rookie year, and he bounced back quite nicely in 2025, having his best season since 2022. However, Lawrence has had a consistent and noticeable drop-off in completion percentage in the last two years, falling from above 65% down to just above 60% during those two seasons. His 2025 ranking was 7th worse in the league and, frankly, the low 60s percentage wise is a low score in today's NFL. Other low scores included a 13th worst in Interceptions thrown and a league average score in Completions and also Escapability.
Lawrence's best stats category was 8th best in the league in TD passes, and 11th best in the NFL in QBR, Yards passing and Yards per attempt. All 4 other categories were above league average.
Trevor Lawrence is not an overwhelming talent in NFL terms, but he is a good solid, above average NFL QB who is also a decent runner. But, most importantly of all, he stays on the field. And that may be the best thing of all.
13) Seattle Seahawks Average category score: 17.636
Record 14-3, Super Bowl Champs
Which came first, the chicken or the egg? The NFL version of this question is which came first, the first round QB bust or the terrible team he plays for? Well, guess what? As soon as former first round "bust" Sam Darnold left the NY Jets and then later the Carolina Panthers, magically, he didn't look so terrible after all. And to be fair, Darnold played relatively well in 2019, his second season with the Jets, finishing with a 7-6 record as the starter, passing for 233 yards per game, completing 62% of his passes with a 1.46 to 1 ratio. So, you could see the potential was there when the team was decent. And as follows, after he left Carolina and had a transition year in San Francisco, Sam Darnold had back-to-back 14-3 records as the starter, first in Minnesota and then in Seattle.
And this is the argument I consistently make. Very few high draft pick QBs who are immediately anointed as the starter on a terrible team succeed. They end up on teams with first time head coaches, starting backs who wouldn't start on other teams, porous offensive lines and number one receivers who would be number threes on a good team. Only an extraordinary talent will make the best of that situation and succeed. Just look at the Seahawks Super Bowl opponent, New England, for confirmation of that. Drake Maye did improve from year one to year two, but the team added many new players and got better as a whole. The Patriots did not go from 4-13 to 14-3 just because Maye improved. That was a total team improvement.
As with Jacksonville above, Sam Darnold was the Seattle QB room, with the exception of three passes thrown by Drew Lock and negative 1 rushing yards on 9 attempts by Lock and Jalen Milroe.
Darnold made hay while the sun shone in four basic areas...first and second, respectively, in Yards per Completion and per Attempt, ninth in Yards Passing and sixth in Completion Percentage. Looking at the combo of those stats would lead one to recognize that his Attempts and Completions numbers were low, both in the bottom 9. He also had 14 Interceptions, which was 7th worst in the league, so that even with his above league average number of TD Passes thrown, his Ratio also suffered, landing him at tenth worst in the NFL.
This mishmash of scoring averages has Darnold as the 13th best QB in a league of 32, but quite obviously good enough to win a championship on a good to great team. And that is sort of my point.
14) Philadelphia Eagles Average category score: 17.545
Record: 11-6, NFC East Champs, Lost in the Wild Card round
The Eagles are another squad with an essentially one-man QB room, although Jalen Hurts did sit out the season finale', giving backup Tanner McKee a game's worth of snaps. Jalen Hurts sort of represents the opposite of Joe Burrow below, in that Burrow is often Hurt and Hurts almost never is! See what I did there?
In general, the NFL passing game has been trending down and the running game is beginning to make a bigger impact on offense again, and maybe nowhere is this more prevalent than in Philly. Two seasons ago, Jalen Hurts passed for 3858 yards, his highest season total. Then, the Eagles signed Saquon Barkley, whom proceeded to run wild in 2024 (2005 rushing yards) and Hurts passed for almost 900 yards less. The balance levelled back a bit last season, with Barkley rushing for 1140 yards and Hurts adding 321 passing yards to his 2024 total. The Eagles team total still could only rise to 10th worst in the league.
As for positives, the Eagles threw the second fewest Interceptions, leading quite directly to a 5th best placement in Ratio. Yards per Attempt and Escapability also landed in the league's top 13. Yards per Completion and TD passes thrown also are also above league average categories. The worst category was Completions, fifth worst in the league and total Attempts, matching the passing yards score as 10th worst in the NFL.
15) Cincinnati Bengals Average category score: 17.500
Record: 6-11, Missed playoffs
Joe Burrow, as always, was great in 2025. When he played, that is. And that is always been the problem with Joe Burrow. He spends a lot of time hurt. In 2021, 2022 and 2024, Joe Burrow started every Bengals game, and the team went a combined 31-18. In his other 3 seasons. Burrow has started 28 of the 50 games the team has played and the team record for those seasons was an almost exactly opposite19-30-1.
Since the Bengals lost the AFC Championship after the 2022 season, the have finished 9-8 twice and 6-11 and have failed to make the playoffs in all three years. Joe Burrow is still really good, but the team around him is not as good as it once was and with their current talent level they really only have a chance for success when he is healthy for the whole season.
And, as an aside, I often like to acknowledge the wisdom of drafting a QB and letting him sit for a bit before starting, but when that doesn't happen and the player is great from game one, that needs to be properly acknowledged, as well. And Joe Burrow, as injury prone as he is, has played like a star from his very first game in his rookie season, as he was made the starter immediately during his first training camp.
When Joe Burrow was out in 2025, the QB duties in Cincinnati last year were handled by the tandem of first Jake Browning in games 2-5 and then the newly acquired Joe Flacco, who had started for Cleveland AGAINST Joe Burrow and the Bengals in week one. And to be entirely fair, Flacco was actually quite good in his 6 starts despite the team being 1-6, finishing with 13 TDs and 4 INTs (a stellar 3.25 to 1 ratio), completing nearly 62% of his passes for 1664 yards.
The overall room, as obvious by their placement here, was not bad. The team finished in the top three in the league in TD Passes thrown, Attempts and Completions and seventh in the league in Yards Passing. The team as a whole threw 17 Interceptions, fifth worst in the league, but a lot of that falls on Browning's 8 picks thrown in 3 and a half games, only one less than the combined total of 9 interceptions thrown by Flacco and Burrow in the other 13 and a half games. So, despite the high score in TD passes, those interceptions dragged down the Ratio to twelfth worst in the league.
No wonder the trade was made for Flacco...Browning was definitely NOT the backup he had been in 2023, when he went 4-3, passing for almost 2000 yards with a 70.4 completion percentage rate while filling in during previous Burrow injury.
In addition, Yards per Attempt, Yards per Completion, QBR and Escapability were all below average, with the first three of those listed being in the NFL bottom 10. The last stat, Completion Percentage, was right at league average.
16) Denver Broncos Average category score: 17.363
Record: 14-3, AFC West champs, lost AFC Championship game
It is very likely that Denver would have been the Seahawks opponent in the Super Bowl had Bo Nix not been injured for the game. After all, Nix's backup, Jarrett Stidham, had one rush for -1 yard for the entire 2025 season. As it was, the Broncos lost to New England at home 10-7 with Nix out.
So, we have already established that Bo Nix was the Denver QB room in 2025. Nix sort of follows both trends about starting a QB as a rookie right away. Bo Nix has been very, very good right out of the box in his 2024 rookie season, much like Joe Burrow above had been in his. But Nix also benefitted from being an older, more mature player on draft day, as he had been a college starter for 5 full seasons. He was 24 on draft day, two years older than the average QB drafted after his senior season. In addition, he was drafted onto a team that wasn't terrible, as the Broncos had finished 8-9 the previous season.
Regardless, Bo Nix has started all 34 games since being drafted and has been a better than average NFL QB and one that seems to be able to lead a good team to victories, finishing his first two seasons with a record of 24-10 with two playoff appearances.
As for 2025, Denver was 3rd in the league in Attempts, 8th highest in Completions, and conversely, Yards per Attempt and per Completion for 5th and 8th worst in the league respectively, as Yards passing was right at league average. TD passes thrown and Completion percentage were the only other items below league average. All other categories saw Denver fall between 14th and twelfth best in the NFL.
17) Tampa Bay Buccaneers Average category score: 17.136
Record: 8-9, missed playoffs
Baker Mayfield is sort of my spirit animal as a quarterback, the poster child for starting too soon and then needing a career resurrection later, at which point everyone finds out the guy wasn't a bust after all. And to be fair, Mayfield was actually pretty good right from jump, mainly just suffering from expectations that were too high due to his being the first overall pick and landing on an inconsistent Cleveland Browns team.
The Browns were 0-16 the year before they drafted Baker Mayfield and finished 7-8-1 the next year with him at the helm, starting in week 4 after initial starter Tyrod Taylor (another 'better than you think he is' QB) suffered a concussion in the third game. Following that season, Mayfield ended up in a pattern of good season followed by a mediocre one for his 4 seasons in Cleveland.
As form follows function, Cleveland gave up on him too soon and after a few years in the wilderness, Baker Mayfield was signed by Tampa before the 2023 season and has been pretty spectacular for the Bucs since then. Although 2025 represented a moderate drop-off in productivity compared to the previous two seasons.
Outside of about a half of a game's worth of snaps for backup Teddy Bridgewater, Mayfield was essentially the Bucs' QB room. What was different in the category scores for Tampa, compared to most teams, is the consistency. Every category fell within 6 spots of the average score, both above and below. The lowest scores were Yards per Attempt, Completion Percentage, Yards per Completion and Yards Passing, where Tampa was, respectively, eleventh, twelfth, thirteenth and fourteenth in the league.
On the other side, QBR, TD Passes and Ratio had Tampa in 10th, 11th and tied for 11th best in the league. The other four statistical categories were all just above league average. In case you were wondering, the biggest statistical anomalies for Mayfield from the previous two seasons, particularly 2024, were in passing yardage and TD passes. The 2025 season was far more like his two good years in Cleveland than his previous two in Tampa. And it shows in the drop in the rankings here, from 4th place last year down 13 places to 17th.
18) Los Angeles Chargers Average category score: 16.954
Record: 11-6, 2nd in the AFC West, lost in Wild card playoff round
While I wouldn't exactly say that Justin Herbert running Jim Harbaugh's offense is like having a Bugatti pull a farm hay wagon, there is a scintilla of truth to the notion. In Herbert's first 4 seasons, he averaged 39 pass attempts per game, or 664 per 17 game season. In the two years since Harbaugh's arrival as head coach, those numbers have dropped to 31 attempts per game, 523 attempts per season, a walloping 141 less per 17 games.
Doing these surveys for 4 years now, I have noticed that passing yards league wide are trending down, but not like they have for Herbert in the 2 years under Harbaugh. Hebert's average passing season yardage has dropped from 4691 yards down to 3798, a drop of almost 900 yards per season, or a 19% decrease. Weirdly, however, this has brought success in the standings as Harbaugh's Chargers have had identical 11-6 records both years, while during the previous 4 years of Herbert's career, the team's average record was 8-9.
Trey Lance appeared in 4 games and accumulated a little more than a game's worth of pass attempts, all but 13 of them coming in the season finale', which he started in order for the Chargers to protect and save Justin Herbert for the playoffs. So, essentially, the QB room was Herbert.
Like the Bucs who immediately proceed them, the Chargers QB room was consistent if not spectacular. The only bottom 10 category was Interceptions (14 thrown between the two QBs) and the scores for Yards per Completion and Ratio were also both just below average for the league. All of the other categories fell within the narrow window of tied for league average (16th best/worst) and 9th best in the NFL, with the most positive being Completions thrown.
In terms of my personal preference as a fan, I would probably feel better with a QB like Baker Mayfield or Justin Herbert who is consistent across most categories. And while he is 18th in this survey, I feel that the lower average scores are more a reflection of the coaching style and I would take the still young Justin Herbert over almost any QB in the league.
19) New Orleans Saints Average category score:16.681
Record: 6-11. missed playoffs
You might be surprised, considering their record, that the Saints QB room wasn't too shabby last year, especially when noting that their two young signal callers, Spencer Rattler and Tyler Shough, were 5th and 2nd round picks in 2024 and 2025, respectively.
What is really surprising is how similarly, in terms of statistics, the two quarterbacks played and yet Shough was far more successful in terms of record, 5-4 in his 9 starts versus 1-7 for Rattler in his 8 starts. More surprising also was that of the three biggest injuries the team suffered during the season, to Chase Young, Alvin Kamara and Chris Olave, two of those occurred in the portion of the season when Shough was starting.
"Portion of the season", however, is the operative term here. Spencer Rattler started the first 8 games in which the Saints played 5 times against eventual playoff teams, including the two Super Bowl contestants, Seattle and New England. Meanwhile, Tyler Shough started the easy half of the schedule against only 2 playoff teams, the Rams and twice against Carolina, who won the division but with a weak 8-9 record. It was 4 straight wins in weeks 14-17 against the Bucs, Panthers, Jets and Titans that made the difference for Shough, record wise.
Outside of a noticeable advantage for Shough in Yards per Attempt and Completion and an opposite advantage for Rattler in the number of times he was sacked (part of Escapability) there was barely any difference between the two statistically. Both passed for a 67.6% Completion percentage, Rattler's Ratio was 1.6 - 1, while Shough's was 1.66 -1 and they even rushed for similar yardage, 186 to 167 yards, advantage to Shough.
Collectively, unlike the previous two teams, New Orleans was, statistically, all over the place, with scores ranging from 5th worst in the league (TD Passes thrown) to 5th BEST in the league in Completions. They were also sixth best in Pass Attempts, 7th in Completion percentage and 10th best in Yards passing. Conversely, QBR was twelfth worst, Yards per Attempt was 7th worst and they were 8th worst in ratio. Essentially, the combo of Rattler and Shough passed a lot but didn't get a lot to show for it in terms of scoring. But I think this still bodes well as both are still young and can improve in terms of scoring and turnovers and New Orleans can safely look elsewhere to improve the team while both Shough and Rattler are contract controlled for a few more years at a good price and can adequately substitute for each other if need be. It is an enviable position to hold in a weak and winnable division.
The Middle Tier - bottom group
20) Kansas City Chiefs Average category score: 16.045
Record 6-11, missed playoffs for the first time since 2013
It is probably a bit weird to start a review of Patrick Mahomes 2025 season by asking you a question about Tom Brady, but here goes: Does anyone remember that 9 year stretch of Brady's career when the Patriots did not win a Super Bowl?
It is relevant because many among the sports world's punditry believed that Brady was, essentially, done by 2011 because after winning championships in 3 of his first 4 playing seasons, the Patriots went from 2005 to 2013 being a really good team, but not a championship team. And most of that coincided with the first big contract that Brady signed following that third championship after the 2004 season.
Patrick Mahomes won 3 championships in his first six seasons as the starting QB, not quite the success rate of Brady, but enough for comparison purposes. And then, as always, when the young QB is great, he has to be paid like he is great once that 4-year rookie contract window has ended. And while Mahomes largely played with the same core group of receivers in his first four seasons as a starter, his receivers room changed drastically with an almost 100% turnover of personnel after his first big contract was signed before the 2022 season. Losing Tyreek Hill to the Dolphins, in particular, hurt.
The big difference between Brady and Mahomes in their post first big contract days was that Brady's BEST QB years were when he wasn't winning championships while Mahomes' work has suffered from the depletion of his receiving corps and overall team. Mahomes' career average of 285 Yards per game, for example, has dropped down to 254 yards per game in the last three seasons. His three worst TD/INT ratio seasons were the last three, as well. And 2025, with his 62.7% completion percentage was the only season in his career under 65.9%.
As for 2025 in comparison to the rest of the league's QB rooms, Kansas City was in the league top 12 in Attempts, Completions and QBR. Escapability, Yards per Completion and Passing Yards were all just above league average. The below average numbers in both TD Passes and Interceptions leads directly the Chiefs' worst score, 7th worst in the league in Ratio. Gone are the halcyon days of 2018-2022 when Mahomes amassed a 4 to 1 Ratio collectively. His last three seasons have seen a very pedestrian collective 2.08 to 1 ratio, including last season's 2 to 1.
21) Baltimore Ravens Average category score: 15.772
Record 8-9, missed playoffs
The 2025 Ravens QB room was mostly Lamar Jackson, although he did miss 4 starts and his play, statistically, was largely reminiscent of his forgettable 2022 season in which he missed 5 starts. The additional work by Tyler Huntley and Cooper Rush as backups didn't appreciably change much about the overall stats line as Lamar Jackson wasn't really playing markedly better than either of those two. The only major stats killer was Rush's 4 Interceptions with zero TD passes thrown, which put a dent in the ratio score. And both Huntley and Rush combined to elevate the team's Completion Percentage with their 72.2% juxtaposed against Jackson's 63.5 percentage.
All of this comes on the heels of Jackson's 2024 season, the best overall year in his career. If you extrapolate out Lamar Jackson's 2025 numbers to a full 17 games, he would have passed for 839 less yards, ran for 459 yards less (half his 2024 total!) and thrown 14 fewer TD passes. Plus, his completion percentage was 3.1 points lower. Mix it all together and what you get is a rather mediocre 2025 QB room made up from a very talented starter and two capable backups. It is a conundrum.
The stats accumulated by the Ravens' passers were largely on the positive side of average, but two glaring problem categories really bring down the overall average, worst in the league in both Attempts and Completions. Combine that with their fifth worst Passing Yards and what do you get? A top 8 finish in both Yards per Attempt (8th) and Yards per Completion (5th) and also in QBR (7th). The TD passes thrown and Interceptions were both at average or below but left the Ratio a bit above average. Huntley and Rush's 72.2% Completion Percentage boosted the Ravens to twelfth best in the NFL and even though Jackson wasn't the same rusher in 2025, both his and Huntley's prowess in the run game put the Ravens a few spaces above league average in Escapability.
I doubt very seriously that Lamar Jackson will have two down seasons in a row but with a new coaching staff in town, he might get off to a slow start in 2026.
22) Pittsburgh Steelers Average category score: 15.681
Record: 10-7, AFC North Champions, Lost in Wild Card round
Finally, after many long years of weirdness and great production, we are finally seeing the slowdown of Aaron Rodgers at age 42. And frankly, in my opinion, he is probably a top 5 QB of all time. This was a guy you could count on for 4000+ passing yards per season, with a ridiculous 4.285 to 1 TD to Interception ratio and completing passes at a 65% rate. Not to mention the "eye test" goodies, such as the ability to drop a 65-yard pass on a dime with a mere flick of the wrist.
But now, time is catching up. Where it seemed to catch up most in 2025 was in the yardage categories. Aaron Rodgers only missed throwing for 4000 or more yards once in a full season between 2008-2021. If you take out 2013 (9 games) and 2017 (7 games), Rodgers averaged 290 yards per game as a starter. In 2025, however, Rodgers averaged 208 yards passing per start, with the overall Steelers' total of 3632 (3322 for Rodgers, 310 for Mason Rudolph) was 11th worst in the NFL, with Yards per Attempt at 8th worst and Per Completion at 5th worst, as the team threw the 10th MOST Completions in the league.
The Steelers' QBR was tied for 8th worst in the league and Escapability was a touch below average, as well. As usual with a Rodgers quarterbacked team, the ratio was 8th best, their best 2025 category, although the 3.43 to 1 ratio was lower than his usual, although it would be great for everyone else. All of the other categories were above average. Mason Rudolph has moved on for 2026 and as usual with Aaron Rodgers these days, we have no idea if he is even playing next season and we probably won't know until week 1 of the preseason. (Hah, wrong on my part! - Rodgers signed a one-year contract in time to appear at OTAs)
23) New York Giants Average category score: 14.818
Record: 4-13, missed playoffs
I think that the Giants might have solved their QB problem. Jaxson Dart was not "great" last year, but he was calm and composed as a rookie starter, and in particular, his 3 to 1 TD to INT ratio speaks volumes. In fact, Jaxson Dart's rookie campaign was statistically similar to Drake Maye's and we all saw where that led in 2025. Jameis Winston and Russell Wilson were both brought in during the offseason with Wilson getting the nod as QB1 to start the season. That lasted for three games and three losses before the team turned to the rookie to start. Notably, when Dart was in concussion protocol later in the season, Jameis Winston started instead of Wilson.
Not to go off on a tangent, but I noticed something very odd when looking at the stats for Wilson and Dart. Wilson's 2024 season stats in Pittsburgh were almost identical to Dart's 2025 stat line. Pittsburgh was 4-2 under Justin Fields in 2024 before switching to Russell Wilson, who in 11 subsequent starts threw for 2482 yards, 16 TDs and 5 INTs with a 63.7 completion percentage (214 completions in 336 attempts). Dart in 2025 was 216/339 (63.7%, also), with 15 TDs and 5 INTs and 2272 yards passing in 12 starts. I would give Jaxson Dart the nod here, though, because the 2025 Giants were a much more inferior team to the 2024 Steelers.
All of this said, the Giants QB room including stats for all three QBs finished 23rd for a reason. This was a team with a wide range of statistical comparison averages, from a high of tenth best in the league in Yards per Completion, right ahead of their 11th best standing in fewest Interceptions thrown. And Dart, Wilson and Winston can all run, so even with a porous offensive line, Escapability was also above average for the league, along with Yards per attempt.
On the other end, TD passes, Completions and Completion Percentage were all in the league's bottom 10. Everything else was muddled in the middle, with the other 4 categories right at or just below league average.
24) Atlanta Falcons Average category score: 14.545
Record: 8-9, missed playoffs
As a Falcons fan, I have already expressed my feelings about the two 2025 Falcons QBs, Michael Penix, Jr. and Kirk Cousins and how I think the previous coaching staff mishandled their QB situation (Kirk Cousins vs. Michael Penix, Jr. Is it time for the Falcons to make a change?) during a season in which the NFC South division title was easily within reach. In summation, if you don't want to read the other blog, my premise was that Cousins, upon returning from the injury that cut short his 2024 season, should have regained the starting QB1 role for 2025.
The weird part is that Cousins and Penix, Jr. had very similar stats in 2025. But much like with the New Orleans Saints and how they simply played better as a team with Tyler Shough behind center, the Falcons also played better with Kirk Cousins starting. And, as much as I scoff at "intangibles" and have set aside won-loss records as a stat, with all other items being somewhat equal, wins and losses on the same team can definitely be a deciding factor. In 2025, piloting the same team, Penix Jr. had a 3-6 record while Cousins went 5-3.
As a combo, the Atlanta QB room had its highest marks in fewest Interceptions thrown, seventh best in the NFL. So even with a low score in TD passes (6th fewest), the ratio was at a respectable tie for 11th best. Other than that, only Yards per Completion and, surprisingly, Escapability were above league average. The surprise is because Cousins is as mobile as a boulder and between the two QBs combined, there was only 77 rushing yards. I guess giving up the 4th fewest sacks in the league counts for something, so kudos to the Falcons 2025 O-line.
For 2026, Kirk Cousins will be in Las Vegas, fending off the ascendancy of number 1 pick Fernando Mendoza while the Falcons attempt to corner the market on lefty QBs after signing Tua Tagavailoa to battle with Michael Penix, Jr.
The also rans
25) Washington Commanders Average category score: 11.363
Record: 5-12, missed playoffs
The Commanders 2025 season was simply a litany of injuries to QB1 Jayden Daniels. But even during his 7 starts, Daniels was not the QB he was in his rookie year and backup Marcus Mariota got the bulk of the snaps on the season while the ancient mariner, 39-year-old journeyman Josh Johnson also banked two starts.
Jayden Daniels' rookie season in 2024 was a sensation. He started all 17 games and led the Commanders to a 12-5 record and a playoff berth, passing for nearly 3600 yards with a 69% completion rate, 25 TDs to only 9 Interceptions and also rushing for almost 900 yards. The 2025 season was not shaping up so successfully for him, even without the injuries. Part of that lies in the inconsistency of his starts...the first two games, followed by injury and missing two games, then three more starts followed by another injury week off, another start, then 3 more games missed followed by one more start in week 14. There is no way to keep things on an even keel when you are never starting more than 3 games in a row.
So, where the Commanders are now is just about where the Texans are with C.J. Stroud, namely is he really as good as his rookie season showed. But first, the answer to that will be answered simply by keeping Jayden Daniels on the field. I suspect that a season of largely uninterrupted playing time probably has the needle pointing back up again.
As far as 2025 was concerned, the QB room was mainly Marcus Mariota melded with Jayden Daniels and a little dash of Josh Johnson. Combined, it cooked a QB meal worthy of Applebee's. Every category was in the bottom 11 in the league with following three exceptions: Yards per Attempt, Yards per Completion and Escapability were all within the TOP 12 in the NFL. Hopefully, 2026 will bring the Commanders the 2024 version of Jayden Daniels and the NFC East will become competitive again.
26) Carolina Panthers Average category score: 10.954
Record: 8-9, NFC South champions, lost in Wild Card playoff round
Okay, we need to be perfectly clear, here. Bryce Young was better last year, and he has consistently (if slowly) improved over his three seasons, but he is not even very good yet. Last year he threw for more yards than he ever has, had his highest season completion percentage (63.6%) and surpassed a 2 to 1 ratio with 23 TD passes to 11 Interceptions. And it paid off for the Panthers, as they won the division even though they were 8-9.
Outside of three games in particular in 2025, week two versus Arizona, week 11 versus Atlanta and week 18 against the Bucs, Bryce Young was still quite pedestrian. Young threw for 1040 yards (more than 1/3 of his season total) with 8 TDs and 1 Interception in those three games. Remove them, and his average Yards per game passing drops by 36 yards from 188 to 152 and his TD to INT ratio drops from 2.09 to 1 down to 1.5 to 1. In other words, that Bryce Young looks a whole lot like the struggling QB of his first two seasons. The results were better for Carolina, but I believe that is far more about the overall team improving as opposed to Bryce Young improving.
In addition to Bryce Young, Andy Dalton also got one start and some additional snaps that added up to one good game, basically. Between the two of them, the team ended up a little below average in most categories, with only Escapability rising above league average, and just above at 16th best. Yards and Yards per Completion were 6th worst and Yards per Attempt was 4th worst in the league. Everything else was between bottom 10 status and league average. Consistent, but below average in all facets.
Ultimately, a better team surrounds Bryce Young, making him seem like he has turned the corner, but the stats tell a different story. The Panthers exercised the fifth-year option, so he has through the 2027 season. Personally, I would not have made that move, considering what other QBs might have been available for $24 million for that season.
27) Miami Dolphins Average category score: 9.272
Record: 7-10, missed playoffs
Tua Tagavailoa's last season in Miami had much in common with every season he has played in both college and the NFL...incomplete. In fact, in 8 seasons as a pro or college QB1, Tagavailoa has only started every one of his team's games twice in a season, 2018 at Alabama and 2023 in Miami. Last year's fourteen starts was the second-best total of his NFL career.
Frankly, 2025 was probably Tua Tagavailoa's worst pro season and it has played out that Miami let him go after the season and he will be competing with Michael Penix. Jr. to start in Atlanta, signed on a veteran minimum salary.
Tagavailoa and Miami's other QBs, Quinn Ewers (3 starts) and Zach Wilson, who barely played, did have the 8th best completion percentage rate, but that was really the only positive, other than a league average score in Yards per Attempt. Everything else was in the bottom 11 of the league, bottoming out at 3rd worst in the league in both Interceptions thrown and Pass Attempts.
Miami is restarting with new signee Malik Willis and Ewers, who frankly was just as good as Tua in 2025, for the rebuild beginning in 2026.
28) Tennessee Titans Average category score: 9.181
Record: 3-14, missed playoffs
Cam Ward was, for all intents and purposes, the entirety of the Titans QB room in 2025. He started all 17 games, although Brandon Allen played the majority of week 18, getting in about a game's worth of snaps, as well. So, right from jump, starting at game one as a rookie and making it through that first season intact and learning the league at this level is a positive enough, something to build on for the future.
Cam Ward was not even terrible, but he was saddled by a not very talented team. Basically, the Passing Yards and the Completion percentage, the usual bugaboos of a rookie, were low. Tennessee as a team had a few high average category scores and a lot of low ones.
Surprisingly, they attempted the 12th most passes on the season, and you could tell that despite that number, this was a low risk, short passes offense, as they also threw the 6th fewest Interceptions and also the 4th fewest Yards passing. Completions and TD/Int Ratio were just below league average and all of the other categories not previously mentioned were 8th worst in the NFL or lower. Only the NY Jets triumvirate threw fewer TD passes per team than Cam Ward's 15 in 2025. The Jets were also the only team to have less Yards per Completion.
Obviously, as with almost every rookie starter, season one is not the judgement point. We will see if the Titans and Cam Ward both improve in the next two seasons before we can truly make a judgement on Ward.
29) Las Vegas Raiders Average category score: 7.863
Record: 3-14, missed playoffs
I feel that Geno Smith is a perfectly capable and viable QB. IF you have a team with average to above average overall talent. But he doesn't seem to elevate a lesser team through his game alone. His game is what it is...good enough to win but not a generation shifting talent. And while this may sound insulting, it is really about where the game of most NFL QBs lies. This is largely why I feel it is a wasted effort to try to go the "Draft your team into greatness by drafting a QB" route.
After a disastrous career start with the Jets, a team that is STILL killing QBs a dozen years later, Geno Smith bounced around a bit before finally landing the starter's role on a pretty good Seahawks team and, lo and behold, he was pretty damn good! Seattle signed him as a backup in 2019 and basically, he was master of the clipboard for two seasons before getting 3 starts while Russell Wilson was injured. Smith's play in those 3 starts was enough to convince Seattle to let Wilson go. Geno Smith then inherited the starter's job and averaged 250 yards passing per game, completing 68.5% of his passes over three seasons and averaging 25 TD passes and 12 Interceptions per season while Seattle slowly built the team that eventually won the Super Bowl the year after he left. Smith also amassed a 27-22 record as Seattle's starter in those three seasons.
Then came the disastrous 2025 season in Las Vegas, where the Seahawks traded him. Smith's completion percentage was still good (67.4%) but his yards per game were down 48 yards, to 202 yards per game. And while he still threw 19 TDs, he also threw 17 Interceptions. I think that much of that aligned with a porous offensive line. Geno Smith was sacked a league leading 55 times in 2025.
In addition to Geno Smith, Kenny Pickett started two games and Aidan O'Connell got playing time in the season ending win, with the latter two amassing about 2 games worth of snaps. Combined, their best score was in Completion Percentage, 11th best in the league. Completions were just below average, but every other category was in the bottom 9 with the exception of finishing tied for 12th worst in the league in Pass Attempts. The worst categories were in Interceptions and QBR, both 2nd worst in the league and 3rd worst scores in both Ratio and Yards per Completion. Geno Smith has moved on for 2026, returning to the rocky shores from whence he started out, the NY Jets. Meanwhile in Vegas, Kirk Cousins has moved in to start and then eventually be supplanted by #1 pick Fernando Mendoza.
30) Minnesota Vikings Average category score: 5.318
Record: 9-8, Missed playoffs
It is becoming at least moderately clear that J. J. McCarthy may not be the answer in Minnesota. The problem is mostly that no one can properly ascertain his talent because he has a hard time staying on the field. He missed his entire first season with a torn meniscus, opening the door for Sam Darnold's breakout season and subsequent signing by Seattle. Season #2, 2025, was more of the same with McCarthy missing 7 games with three different ailments. He did manage to finish 6-4 in his ten starts, but I think that was more about the overall talent level of the team, which had finished the previous season at 14-3 with Darnold behind center. Frankly, at least statistics wise, McCarthy wasn't very good despite that record.
The other starts were divided by the (very) unfairly maligned Carson Wentz, with five, and the other two starts were made by Max Brosmer. Wentz was really the best QB on the team, passing for 243 yards per game with a 65.1% completion rate. Wentz was also the only QB on the team with a positive TD/INT ratio with 6 TD passes and 5 Interceptions, while McCarthy was 11/12 and Brosmer was 0/4. As you might guess, the QB room finished worst in the league in both Interceptions thrown AND Ratio.
Beyond that, as you might expect, the team only had one score out of the bottom ten in the league, the twelfth worst score in Yards per Completion. Every other category score falls between 3rd worst and tied for 9th worst.
The Vikings nabbed Kyler Murray on the cheap during the offseason to compete with McCarthy to start in 2026. And they both should watch out...Wentz is still lurking in the background. I wonder if Vikings management would listen to me and just give Wentz a season of starts. The precedent was already set with Darnold...maybe they can catch lightning in a bottle twice.
31) Cleveland Browns Average category score: 5.045
Record: 5-12, Missed playoffs
Honestly, considering the mess at QB in Cleveland, it is somewhat remarkable that there were 5 other NFL teams that had a worse record in 2025.
Joe Flacco started the first 4 games, finishing at 1-3 before being traded to Cincinnati. Dillon Gabriel got the next 6 starts, with 1 win and 5 losses before bowing out into the concussion protocol. To close out the last 7 games of the season, Shadeur Sanders stepped in, going 3-4. Sanders beat the 3-14 Raiders, the Steelers and the 6-11 Bengals, but also lost to the Titans (3-14) in what was his best game as a QB. On the surface, just looking at the record, this looks like the Tyler Shough vs. Spencer Rattler battle in New Orleans, where the team just plays better under one QB versus the others, even though they are statistically similar. But Sanders is extremely raw and frankly, not very good so far.
And lurking in the background of all of this is Deshaun Watson, who will be returning from injury and may re-inherit the starter's role by default. What a story it would be if Watson could finally re-find his Texans form, but that may never happen. Cleveland is one of those QB wasteland teams, like Indianapolis, who need to stop flipping QBs every other year and just stick to one. Consistently searching for your franchise QB is a great way to ensure that you never find him. Baker Mayfield WAS that guy and they let him walk, and signing Deshaun Watson seemed like a good idea (outside of the price), but I certainly didn't expect him to bomb like he has.
As for 2025, bomb is the word. You can't even really tell who was the "best" QB on the team. Flacco passed for a 58.1% in Cleveland, with 2 TDs and 6 Interceptions and then immediately got better when traded to Cincinnati. Dillon Gabriel threw 7 TDs and only 2 Interceptions, which is really nice and also immediately becomes understandable when you realize he was also only throwing for an abysmal 5.07 yards per attempt. It is hard to throw INTs when you are throwing a bunch of 5-to-8-yard passes. Shadeur Sanders, threw 7 TDs against 10 Interceptions, also only averaging a very low 6.6 yards per attempt. If you extrapolate out Sanders' stats over 17 games, he would have passed for 3173 yards, with a 56.6% completion rate with 16 TDs and 23 Interceptions. Very rookie-like with lots of room for improvement.
Bottom line is that the Browns' QB room only finished above league average in one category, Pass Attempts. Outside of Escapability (tied for 12th worst), all of the other categories have scores in the bottom 8 in the league, and all of them except that 8th worst score in Completions were in the bottom 4.
32) New York Jets Average category score: 4.681
Record: 3-14, Missed playoffs
And now we have reached the bottom of the survey, closing out with the other guaranteed QB killer franchise, the New York Jets. The Jets also had a true QB triumvirate, with Justin Fields, Tyrod Taylor and Brady Cook all getting at least 4 starts on the season. And as the old saw goes, if you have three starters, you have no starters.
To be fair, though, Justin Fields wasn't terrible in starting the Jets first 9 games, except for the abysmal average of 140 yards passing per game. Fields' Completion percentage was 62.7%, not great but acceptable in the NFL. He threw 7 TDs versus only 1 Interception in those games, as well. The team was 2-7 at that point, however, and decided that they might as well make a switch. That would have been less surprising if the backup they turned too had been the young Cook, but they went to 36-year-old journeyman, Tyrod Taylor, instead.
Tyrod Taylor is another guy, much like Fields, who probably has always had too short a leash as a starter. I have made mention many times in other posts that Taylor was rather effective in his three years as Buffalo's starter before Josh Allen came along. He even made a Pro Bowl during that stint. Truthfully, the Jets already had Taylor when they took a chance on signing Fields. They probably should have just gone with Taylor, but hey, it's New York and you HAVE to general manage that team with the media in mind, always.
Signing him wasn't that bad a move, either, as Fields had actually been pretty good the year before in Pittsburgh before getting the early hook, getting the team off to a 4-2 start before being supplanted by Russell Wilson, who had been signed to be the starter but started off the year injured. And it should be noted that Wilson WAS better than Fields that year, also.
The last thing of note from 2025 for the Jets is that at least they learned that Brady Cook is not really ready to be an NFL starter, once they finally went to him for four starts to close out the season. But honestly, no Jets QB had a chance last year as they were getting sacked and harassed all season behind that sieve of an offensive line. The only reason the Escapability score was tied for league average, their best score, was that both Fields and Taylor can flat run. Together, they averaged 5.37 yards per carry in their 98 attempts. And, if you add Fields' 4 TD runs to his 7 TD passes, he was responsible for 11 TDs and just a single Interception. I might have kept him in the starting lineup based on that alone.
As for the rest of the stats, the Jets QBs finished last in the league in 4 categories... TD passes, Yards, Yards per Attempt and Yards per Completion. They also finished 3rd or 4th worst in an additional four categories, and 7th worst in Attempts and 10th worst in Interceptions.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Looking ahead to 2026
Once again, the ever-revolving carousel of teams searching for a QB fix rolls ever onward. I think that the most interesting thing that is happening on the QB front heading into 2026 is the signing of released veteran QBs to league minimum contracts. I am not sure how this will play out in Atlanta or Las Vegas, but it is quite possible that a team with the overall talent level that the Vikings have might be able recreate 2024 again with their signing of Kyler Murray after his release by the Cardinals. He still has some upside potential, more, I think, that Tua Tagavailoa or a 37-year-old Kirk Cousins. That said, however, Arizona felt comfortable enough with Jacoby Brissett's 2025 performance to go ahead and rid themselves of Murray's contract, which means they certainly didn't think he was really a better option than Jacoby. I guess it all remains to be seen. And it is always possible that the Vikings decide to go with J.J. McCarthy. It is a gamble as "initials as a first name" QBs are notoriously not good. Only C.J Stroud bucks that trend.
Cousins is still pretty good, but the Raiders are terrible and he won't be able to fix that...it will be 2025 Geno Smith version 2.0. Plus, Cousins is there just to ease Mendoza into the starter's role eventually. Tua is probably better than Michael Penix, Jr. and both are equally injury prone, but would anyone be shocked if all that signing him nets the Falcons is another season right around .500? Unless Kevin Stefanski is a markedly better coach than I imagine him to be. Still, even that could win the NFC South.
Geno Smith will, at least, stabilize the Jets QB situation. He was able to stay on the field behind the Raiders' o-line last year and he should be able to in 2026, as well. The Jets just need to get some self-awareness and realize they are a year or two away (perpetually?) and just stop dickering with starting QBs. What could it possibly hurt them to just let Geno play 17 games and see if things can improve by season's end versus just benching him despite how well he might be playing, like they did in 2025 with Justin Fields? After all, would Cade Klubnik, Bailey Zappe or Brady Cook improve things much? Because that is who you have to go to if you bench Smith.
The only other team definitely making a change at QB is Miami. Malik Willis looked really great backing up Jordan Love the last two seasons in Green Bay and seems to have found what he had been missing in his first years in Tennessee. He signed a pretty hefty, starter's money kind of contract for someone who is still rather unproven. Hopefully, Willis will live up to it, although last year's draft pick, Quinn Ewers, will wait in the wings to catch his potential fall. Either way, I wouldn't expect too much from Miami this season, although their 2025 record was better than their QB play would have suggested.
The only other potential or real changes are Jacoby Brissett taking over full time in Arizona and the possibility that a healthy Deshaun Watson may once again take the reins in Cleveland. Other than that, everyone else will likely stand pat with who they have, although injuries ALWAYS have a say.
Comments
Post a Comment